Give an agency clear feedback on creative against the brief

Help me give feedback on creative work from my agency or design team. The brief (or key points): [OBJECTIVE, audience, single message, mandatories, channel and format] The work: [PASTE copy, describe the visuals, or list concepts A/B/C] Brand guidelines that apply: [tone, logo use, colors, claims rules] Stakeholder comments I've received: [PASTE, including conflicting ones] Round and deadline: [e.g. "round 2 of 3, final due Friday"] Do this: 1. Evaluate each piece against the brief: Does it land the single message within 3 seconds? Is it right for the audience and the channel (thumb-stopping on mobile, legible at small sizes, works without sound)? Is the call to action clear? 2. Separate objective issues (off-brief, brand violations, legal or claims risks, accessibility like contrast and text size) from subjective preferences. 3. Consolidate conflicting stakeholder comments into one direction and note which I need to resolve before sending. 4. Write feedback as problems to solve, not solutions to execute ("The offer gets lost behind the image" rather than "make the logo bigger"), unless a mandatory is broken. Return: - A verdict per piece: proceed / revise / drop. - Prioritized feedback (must fix, should fix, consider), max 8 points per piece. - The feedback message to send, warm and direct, under 250 words.